St. Paul's Episcopal Church, Key West

St. Paul’s Episcopal Church sits just off Duval Street in the heart of Old Town and is one of Key West’s best-known churches. While it looks traditional from a distance, the building is actually made of solid concrete, chosen for protection against hurricanes and fire. Its construction was influenced by the same practical approach used in Henry Flagler’s Over-Sea Railroad era, when durable materials mattered in the Keys.

The parish itself is much older than the current structure. St. Paul’s was founded in 1831, and its first service was held on Christmas Day 1832. Over the years, it became a steady part of community life on the island, serving locals through changing times, storms, and rebuilding. Stepping inside today, the church still feels like an active place, not only a historic site.

One of the highlights is the interior, especially the stained-glass windows, some of which are linked to Tiffany Studios. The light and color inside are a big part of what visitors remember, along with the high ceilings and the quiet atmosphere. Even a short visit gives a chance to notice the craftsmanship and detail up close.

As of 2026, St. Paul’s is also in the middle of a real preservation challenge. The concrete was made with saltwater aggregate, and over time this has contributed to rusting rebar and cracking walls, so restoration work is underway to help protect the building for the future.